中国洞察:地方政府财政状况如何并不算坏
THIS CONTENT MAY NOT BE DISTRIBUTED TO MAINLAND CHINA
Fiscal income received by local governments has suffered an unprecedented decline due to COVID-19… …but funding from other sources, including the central government and local bond sales, is making up the shortfall While municipal bonds are ignored by foreign investors, we show why they’re important as they become too big to ignore 7 July 2020
A dent to the finances of local governments COVID-19 has depleted China’s local governments of a key source of revenue. In the
first five months of this year, local fiscal income – which comes from taxes on the local economy – dropped by 10.4% y-o-y. In Hubei Province, where Wuhan is the capital, it fell by as much as 42% y-o-y. To make matters worse, spending by local governments is expected to rise, leading to a dramatic rise in their funding gap. All of this is important as local governments are a key part of China’s financial system given these entities have issued vast amounts of debt and fund all sorts of projects. Strong support from the central government, but with conditions attached The good news is there is funding support from a variety of other sources. Transfer payments from the central government are rising, while local governments have been given the green light to issue more municipal bonds (Munis). As a result, total cash inflows into local governments are expected to grow 9.1% this year, based on estimates by Ministry of Finance, not bad at all. Besides, the shadow fiscal system, operated through local government funding vehicles (LGFVs), has been on a fundraising spree in the first four months of this year. However, this time round, conditions have been put in place on local governments by the central government to reduce wasteful investment and careless spending, a different tactic from the “all in” approach during the Global Financial Crisis. Munis: too big to ignore Foreign investors often neglect Munis, and for good reasons. They offer low spreads, poor liquidity and there’s no rating differentiation. However, Munis have grown into the biggest bond class in the onshore market, and most importantly, banks have binged on them at the expense of credit bonds and policy bank bonds. We believe this trend will continue as the Muni supply gets larger. That indicates credit bonds will be unable to rely so much on bank purchases, leaving asset managers to fill the void. Moreover, if banks keep increasing their allocation to Munis, they may ask for more compensation in the form of higher spreads. If that happens, then foreign investors may buy given the low risk, steady supply and long tenor. Helen Huang Analyst, Fixed Income The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited helendhuang@hsbc.com.hk +852 2996 6585
Disclosures & Disclaimer This report must be read with the disclosures and the analyst certifications in the Disclosure appendix, and with the Disclaimer, which forms part of it. Issuer of report: The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited
View HSBC Global Research at: https://www.research.hsbc.com China Fixed Income Credit Local governments’ financial health? Not too bad China Onshore Insights
Fiscal income’s COVID-19 crunch
An unprecedented drop in local fiscal income is being mitigated by a significant step-up in payments from the central government But this may not immediately translate into economic activity as there’s tighter control on local governments over wasteful investment Munis have become the largest bond class in the onshore market but their impact is not yet fully appreciated
This report continues our deep dives into local government debt There is no doubt that the outbreak of COVID-19 has badly hit a key source of revenue for local governments: fiscal income from the local economy. That’s a potential worry as the financial health of local governments has major implications for economic growth. These entities have issued large amounts of debt which fund all sorts of projects and are a critical part of the country’s credit system. In this report, we offer a comprehensive review of cash flow into local governments this year and conclude that the situation is not very bad, for now. This report also continues our previous analysis into this vital part of China’s financial system (see Local government debt: the knowns and unknowns, 4 Oct 2018 and Local government debt: What’s changed? 16 Sep 2019).
A RMB11.5trn problem
One important source of revenue for local governments, and certainly the most straight-forward, is self-generated general fiscal income, which comes from taxes on the local economy. This dropped by 10.4% y-o-y in the first five months of this year, an unprecedented decline. Normally it rises and did so even during the Global Financial Crisis (Fig 1). According to the national budget plan published in May, a decline of 3.5% is now expected for 2020. However, at the same time, local governments’ general fiscal spending is expected to increase by 4.2%. That means there’s going to be a widening funding gap, which Ministry of Finance expects to reach as much as RMB11.5trn this year, a historic high (Fig 2). On the face of it, this looks very worrying, though as we later explain, there are also reasons not to be overly concerned.
1. Growth rate of local governments’ self-generated general fiscal income and general fiscal expenses
40.0%
30.0%
20.0%
10.0%
0.0%
-10.0%
-20.0%
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Local government self-generated general fiscal income, growth YoY Local government general fiscal expenses, growth YoY
Source: Wind, HSBC. Data as of May 2020.
2. Widening gap between local governments’ self-generated general fiscal income and general fiscal expenses
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
-
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020E
Local government self-generated general fiscal income, RMBbn Local government general fiscal expenses, RMBbn
Source: Wind, HSBC, Ministry of Finance estimates
In provinces that were worst hit by the COVID-19 outbreak, self-generated general fiscal income declined by even more. Table 3 shows that in Hubei Province, where Wuhan is the capital city, this metric dropped by as much as 42% y-o-y in the first five months of this year. As Table 3 shows, out of the 31 provinces, 18 reported double-digit declines in the first four months of this year, and the rest had either negative or flat growth. Perhaps more worrying is that the COVID-19 outbreak is not even the single biggest contributing factor to the recent decline in fiscal income. Some provinces were already struggling with a decline in self-generated general fiscal income because the local economy was slowing and because of tax cuts. The virus has merely accelerated these existing trends. For example, in Hubei Province, growth in self-generated general fiscal income had remained in the low single digits from 2016 to 2019 before the outbreak. And in Chongqing City, general fiscal income declined by 5.8% in 2019 and by 16.8% y-o-y in the first fourth months of 2020. RMBbn
3. Growth of general fiscal income, by province, as of April 2020
Provinces
2019, y-o-y
Jan – April 2020, y-o-y
Hubei
2.5%
-43.7%
Hainan
8.2%
-30.1%
Heilongjiang
-1.6%
-21.7%
Inner Mongolia
10.9%
-18.9%
Shanxi
2.4%
-18.3%
Tianjin
14.4%
-17.7%
Chongqing
-5.8%
-16.8%
Shaanxi
2.0%
-16.0%
Jilin
-10.0%
-14.9%
Liaoning
1.4%
-14.8%
Ningxia
-4.7%
-14.3%
Shanghai
0.8%
-13.0%
Gansu
-2.4%
-12.8%
Beijing
0.5%
-12.3%
Sichuan
4.1%
-11.9%
Fujian
1.5%
-11.6%
Xinjiang
3.0%
-11.6%
Henan
7.4%
-11.5%
Guangdong
4.5%
-8.5%
Shandong
0.6%
-8.5%
Hebei
6.5%
-8.2%
Jiangsu
2.0%
-7.8%
Guizhou
2.3%
-7.7%
Hunan
5.1%
-6.2%
Jiangxi
4.8%
-4.2%
Zhejiang
6.8%
-4.1%
Yunnan
4.0%
-3.9%
Qinghai
3.4%
-1.3%
Guangxi
7.8%
-0.4%
Tibet
-3.6%
0.4%
Anhui
4.4%
NA
All provinces*
Source: Wind, HSBC
3.2%
-11.5%
Note*: Excluding Anhui, which has not reported local fiscal income information this year.
The resilience of this key metric has also varied widely by region. The coastal East region has fared relatively better in generating tax revenues at a local level than inland regions (see Figure 4 below), thanks to its much larger and active private sector. This supports our argument made in the previous report that the virus outbreak has prompted Beijing to increase the strategic importance of the private sector to help bring more stability to the economy (see our report Default data – what to watch for in a time of COVID-19, 25 March 2020).
4. Growth rate of self-generated general fiscal income, by regions, as of April 2020
10%
5%
0%
-5%
-10%
-15%
-20%
Middle
Northeast
West
East 2016 2017
2018
2019 April 2020
Source: Wind, HSBC
Note: Middle Region excludes Anhui Province, which has not disclosed general fiscal revenue this year. Middle Region includes Hubei Province, where Wuhan is capital city.
Payments from the central government is more stable
However, all this is just one part of the story. Investors shouldn’t rush to a view about the financial health of local governments based just on this metric. Over the past decade, the importance of self-generated general fiscal income has actually declined for local governments. Its share of total cash inflow into local governments has declined from 46% in 2007 to 35% in 2019, and is expected to decline further to 31% this year, according to estimates by Ministry of Finance, as Fig 5 shows.
5. Breakdown of total cash inflows into local governments per year, 2007 to 2020e
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020E
General fiscal income: self-generated General fiscal income: transferred from central gov
Gov fund income Income from SOE ownership Net Muni issuance
Source: Wind, local governments, HSBC, Ministry of Finance estimates
0%
19%
0%
3%
2% 0%
2% 2% 3%
1%
6%
1%
22%
22
1%
%
30%
26
%
22
22%
15%
1%
%
28
27%
5%
31%
32
29
28%
%
27%
%
26
%
6% 47%
44
%
41%
44
%
46
%
%
35
%
%
31
%
%
%
%
%
4
38
41
39
43
42
44
%
27
%
%
%
%
%
%
24
25
26
26
26
3
27
%
%
%
%
%
%
28
26
0%
29
0%
30
%
119%
1%
1%
7%
2%
32
As Chart 6 below shows, local government’s fiscal book is split into two accounts: the general fiscal account and the government fund account, and each account collects revenue from different sources and conducts spending for different purposes. The most badly hit item – self- generated general fiscal income – is just one part of this sprawling funding system for local governments and does not tell the whole story. General fiscal account The general fiscal account collects revenue mainly from taxes on businesses and individuals. More than half the income under the general fiscal account is generated at a local level, referred to as self-generated general fiscal income, which as mentioned above declined by 10.4% y-o-y in the first five months of this year. But payments from the central government which also contribute to the general fiscal account is an important source too, as shows in Item 1 in Chart 6. The final source of cash for this account is from the issuance of General Muni (municipal) bonds. Appetite for these bonds rests on the ability of local governments to collect tax as well as payments into the general fiscal income account from the central government. Money in the general fiscal account is spent on items like wages for government staff and subsidies for local schools and corporates. Such spending is considered an “expense” because the spending will not form assets that can generate cash flow in the future. Government fund account The other separate fiscal account is the government fund account. Revenue under this account is collected mainly from land sales at a local level. The central government has historically made very small transfer payments to local governments under this account. The remaining cash flow is provided by the issuance of Project Muni (municipal) bonds. Appetite for these rests on local governments’ ability to sell land and to collect income from projects built by the proceeds of these bonds. Funds from this account are spent on items like cleaning up a piece of land for auction, building a road or a utility plant. These items are considered “investments” because the spending will form assets that are able to generate cash flow in the future. Theoretically, in rare situations where the government fund account dries up and attempts to refinance Project Muni bond fails, these bonds can default and local governments do not bear any obligation to use tax income in the general fiscal account to pay back bondholders of Project Munis. For this reason, the issuance of Project Munis is not counted in China’s official fiscal deficit. To be clear, only two types of bonds are counted: Chinese Government Bonds (CGBs, though excluding special CGBs to be issued this year) and General Munis. All three items marked in Chart 6 are expected to be either stable or to grow significantly this year. They are a stable source of cash for local governments, especially now when self-generated general fiscal income faces challenges. We will discuss below these three items one by one. 6. Structure of local governments’ fiscal accounts, illustration Local governments’ fiscal book
Source: Ministry of Finance, HSBC
General fiscal account
Government fund account
In coming
Out coming
In coming
Out coming
=
=
Proceeds from issuance
3 of Project Muni
central government
2 Transfer payment from
2 Self-generated government fund income (mainly from land sales)
Proceeds from issuance
3 of General Muni
1 Transfer payment of general fiscal income
from central government
Self-generated general fiscal income
(mainly from taxes)
Investment type of government spending
Expense type of government spending
1. Transfer payment of general fiscal income from the central government This is a mechanism whereby the Ministry of Finance collects revenues from local economies and then re-distributes it back to local governments. To be exact, VAT, corporate income tax and individual income tax are collected from local economies and then split between local and central governments. The amount that goes into local governments become part of their self-generated general fiscal income, and the amount that goes into central governments are pooled together and then re-distributed to local governments. Rich provinces are net payers and poor provinces are net receivers, making it an important channel for wealth redistribution in the country. Transfer payments to local governments significantly increased in 2019 as the central government stepped up to support local governments to help them weather a reduction in tax revenue after a tax cut on corporates and individuals. This year, the Ministry of Finance will further increase transfer payments to local governments under this account by RMB950bn to RMB8.4trn (Fig 7), representing a growth rate of 12.8% y-o-y. This extra money comes from the increased issuance of China Government Bonds (CGB). According to the budget plan published in May, the issuance quota of normal CGBs for this year is expanded by RMB950bn to RMB2.78trn, and all proceeds from this increase will be transferred to local governments’ general fiscal income.
7. Transfer payment of general fiscal income from the central government
9,000
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
-
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020E
General fiscal income: transferred from central gov
General fiscal income: transferred from central gov, growth YoY, RHS
30.0%
25.0%
20.0%
15.0%
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
Source: Wind, Ministry of Finance, HSBC
2. Government fund income As mentioned earlier, government fund income comes mainly from sales of local land to property developers. Historically, the Ministry of Finance has made small transfer payments to local governments under this account. It also fluctuated a lot from year to year, depending on the sentiment of the property market. For this year, because of the slowdown in land sales, local governments’ self-generated government fund income declined 3.1% y-o-y in the first five months and is expected to decline 3.3% for the whole year, according to the budget plan published in May. The central government though is stepping in to support and make up the shortfall. It plans to make as much as RMB800bn of transfer payments this year to local governments under the government fund account. That compares to 2019 when the central government only transferred RMB90bn. As to where the money comes from, the central government will issue RMB1trn of special CGBs this year and all proceeds will be used to make transfer payment to local governments. With this large one-off transfer payment from the central government, the government fund income is expected to grow 5.5% y-o-y in 2020, as Fig 8 shows. RMBbn
8. Government fund income, amount and growth y-o-y
10,000
9,000
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
-
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020E
Gov fund income (including transfer payment from central government)
120.0%
100.0%
80.0%
60.0%
40.0%
20.0%
0.0%
-20.0%
-40.0%
Gov fund income (including transfer payment from central government), growth YoY, RHS
Source: Wind, HSBC, Ministry of Finance estimates
3. Enlarged Muni issuance quota Lastly, this year’s Muni issuance quota is expanded significantly to help local governments raise cash. As Fig 9 shows, the net Muni issuance quota, including General Munis and Project Munis, increased by 54% this year to RMB4.73trn, which is roughly equivalent to 4.5% of the country’s GDP. It is worth noting that the rapid increase of Muni issuance quota is largely driven by growth in Project Munis. And as mentioned above, there are clear restrictions as to how local governments can spend the proceeds raised from these bond sales. Specifically, the proceeds can only be used to invest in projects that can generate cash flow to pay back Project Muni bondholders. As an example, local governments cannot use the proceeds from the issuance of Project Munis to distribute cash to local residents to boost local consumption. Some local governments struggle to find enough viable local projects that can generate reasonable cash in the future, and without enough viable projects, the issuance quota may not be fully tapped. Restrictions to the usage of Project Muni proceeds also mean that not all the local fiscal power can be freely translated into immediate economic activity or corporate bailouts. This is one aspect that shows that China’s fiscal stimulus approach today is more conservative than during the Global Financial Crisis, when “all in” was the theme. More considerations are now given to the sustainability of fiscal stimulus. 9. Muni issuance quota vs. GDP
5,000
4,500
4,000
3,500
3,000
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
-
Source: Wind, HSBC
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Muni issuance quota - General Muni Muni issuance quota - Project Muni
Muni issuance quota as % of GDP, RHS
5.0%
4.5%
4.0%
3.5%
3.0%
2.5%
2.0%
1.5%
1.0%
0.5%
0.0%
RMBbn
RMBbn
Thanks to multiple sources of cash, local government’s consolidated income that includes transfer payments from the central government and the government fund income is expected to grow at 3.9%. Moreover, total cash inflows that also include proceeds from net Muni issuance is expected to grow at 9.1%, as Fig 10 shows. To put it more specifically, this year local governments’ self-generated general fiscal income is expected to reach RMB9.75trn, while total cash inflow into local governments is expected to reach as much as RMB31.65trn, as Fig 11 shows. This amount is equivalent to as much as 31% of China’s GDP in 2020, all in cash.
10. Growth rate of local governments’ fiscal income and total cash inflow, y-o-y
45.0%
40.0%
35.0%
30.0%
25.0%
20.0%
15.0%
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
-5.0%
-10.0%
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2020E
General fiscal income: self-generated Consolidated local government income Total cash inflows
Source: Wind, HSBC, Ministry of Finance estimates
11. Amount of local governments’ self-generated general fiscal income and total cash inflow
35,000
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
-
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020E
General fiscal income: self-generated Consolidated local government income Total cash inflows
Source: Wind, HSBC, Ministry of Finance estimates
RMBbn
The shadow fiscal system is back
Unfortunately, the story is not yet complete. Up to now, we have discussed the local governments’ explicit fiscal system, but they have also built a massive shadow fiscal system that centres on local government funding vehicles (LGFVs). These help to make investments and conduct spending that local governments are not able to make through their explicit fiscal accounts. And LGFVs raise money from the market on the back of both the implicit guarantee provided by local governments and LGFVs’ own credit fundamentals, to a certain extent. Thanks to easy monetary conditions and that China’s deleveraging campaign has been put to one side for now amid the economic doldrums, LGFVs received a windfall in financing up to April of this year, surpassing even 2016, which was the previous peak (see Fig 12). Issuance has slowed down since May as the policy stance towards monetary easing turned more cautious. But with a vast amount of funds already raised, it is difficult to foresee LGFVs running into major financing difficulties in the second half. Though as we argued before (Local
government debt: What’s changed?, 16 Sep 2019), credit differentiation will continue to deepen in the LGFV sector, and those with weak fundamentals are particularly at risk.
12. Net issuance by LGFVs in the onshore bond market
1,400
1,200
1,000
800
600
400
200
-
(200)
2015 2016 2017
2018
2019 2020
Source: Wind, HSBC. Data as of June 2020.
Many investors may ask why local governments’ fiscal accounts have to be so complicated. Well, for the sake of simplicity, we have actually skipped various other mechanisms like balancing funds, income and expenses related to the management of SOEs and social security funds that are also closely correlated with local fiscal management. For decades, local governments have been constrained by tight control over their official deficit, which has led them to develop alternative funding channels. This is also how the sprawling shadow banking system started in the first place, providing additional financing to local governments’ investment initiatives as well as property developers’ land purchases, in which the payment for land ultimately goes to local governments. Some progresses have been made since 2015 in cleaning up local governments’ fiscal system, but we believe far more needs to be done. Such changes would require painful reforms and tough negotiations between central and local governments, and could take years if not decades. Developing China’s financial system in a healthy manner would depend on the progress of fiscal Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
RMBbn
reforms, because that will help redefine the role of both local and central government in participating in economic activity. While uncertainty remains over the long-term fiscal condition of local governments, our analysis shows that for this year, the impact of the COVID-19 outbreak on local governments’ overall fiscal situation is manageable, in our view.
Munis – too big to ignore
In the last section of this report, we explain the world of Munis. Issuance of these local government bonds started in 2009 but only took off in 2015. Since then, growth has been so fast that in less than six years’ time, it has become the biggest bond class in the onshore market. Munis do not offer much attraction for foreign investors for obvious reasons: low yields and low liquidity. As of March 2020, foreign investors based offshore hold only RMB2.6bn of Munis. But Munis occupy so much space in the onshore market that their influence on overall market sentiment is very significant, and that is not always fully appreciated.
13. Munis outstanding in the China’s onshore bond market
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
-
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020E
Munis outstanding, RMBbn
Source: Wind, HSBC, Ministry of Finance estimates
Issuer mix There are 38 issuers in the Muni space, which include 31 provinces, five cities that enjoy vice- provincial administrative ranking, one special corporate that enjoys provincial administrative ranking (Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps) and the Ministry of Finance (Table 14). The RMB59bn of Munis outstanding that have the Ministry of Finance as the nominal issuer is a legacy product: before 2011, local governments could only issue Munis through the Ministry of Finance, who would then distribute the issuance proceeds to local governments. But from 2011, selective local governments also began to issue Munis under their own names. In 2015, the Ministry of Finance stopped issuing Munis on behalf of local governments. RMBbn
14. Muni bonds outstanding by issuer
Issuer Administrative ranking
Amount outstanding, RMBbn
% in total amount outstanding
Jiangsu Provincial
1,660
6.9%
Guangdong Provincial
1,371
5.7%
Shandong Provincial
1,331
5.6%
Sichuan Provincial
1,198
5.0%
Zhejiang Provincial
1,164
4.9%
Hunan Provincial
1,125
4.7%
Guizhou Provincial
1,015
4.2%
Hebei Provincial
993
4.1%
Henan Provincial
909
3.8%
Yunnan Provincial
906
3.8%
Anhui Provincial
893
3.7%
Hubei Provincial
879
3.7%
Inner Mongolia Provincial
761
3.2%
Fujian Provincial
723
3.0%
Shaanxi Provincial
710
3.0%
Liaoning Provincial
697
2.9%
Guangxi Provincial
694
2.9%
Jiangxi Provincial
657
2.7%
Chongqing Provincial
631
2.6%
Shanghai Provincial
619
2.6%
Beijing Provincial
594
2.5%
Tianjin Provincial
572
2.4%
Heilongjiang Provincial
523
2.2%
Xinjiang Provincial
522
2.2%
Jilin Provincial
477
2.0%
Shanxi Provincial
395
1.7%
Gansu Provincial
360
1.5%
Hainan Provincial
242
1.0%
Qinghai Provincial
229
1.0%
Ningxia Provincial
174
0.7%
Tibet Provincial
28
0.1%
Ningbo Vice-provincial
208
0.9%
Dalian Vice-provincial
200
0.8%
Qingdao Vice-provincial
186
0.8%
Xiamen Vice-provincial
105
0.4%
Shenzhen Vice-provincial
72
0.3%
Central Ministry of Finance State
59
0.2%
Xinjiang Production and Provincial Construction Corps
41
0.2%
Total
23,920
100.0%
Source: Wind, HSBC. Data as of 26 June 2020.
Tenor For the RMB23.9trn of Muni bonds outstanding, their remaining tenors are distributed quite evenly from 1 year to 10 years, as Fig 15 shows. In the primary issuance market, however, the most popular tenors are 5 years, 7 years and 10 years, as Fig 16 shows. Clearly, Muni bonds have much longer tenors than most corporate bonds.
15. Muni bonds outstanding, breakdown by remaining tenor
16. Muni bonds outstanding, breakdown by issuance tenor
Source: Wind, HSBC Source: Wind, HSBC
Rating All Muni bonds that were publicly issued have a bond rating of AAA by domestic rating agencies. For those that were issued privately to selective investors instead of publicly auctioned in the open market, no rating is provided. No ratings on issuers, which are local governments, is provided either. So there is no rating differentiation for Munis at all. A point that can slightly mitigate this is that Muni’s credit risk, either for General Munis or Project Munis, is very limited. Most Munis will be refinanced when they come due, and the chances of them failing to do so is quite small, given how important they are to the onshore credit market. Investor mix Banks have always been the dominant investors in the onshore bond market, and it is particularly so in the Muni space. As Fig 17 shows, 86% of Munis outstanding were held by commercial banks as of March 2020. This amounts to RMB19.4trn of Munis on commercial banks’ balance sheets, accounting for 6.4% of commercial banks’ total assets and 40% of their total bond holdings, as of March 2020 (Fig 18). Note that commercial banks’ large holdings of Munis have been built up in pretty much just six years – Munis accounted for only 5% of commercial banks’ bond holdings in Dec 2014 (Fig 19). In fact, the supply of Munis has been so large and so overwhelmingly absorbed by commercial banks that over the period from 2015 to March 2020, 62% of the RMB29.48trn net increase in bond holdings by commercial banks were Munis. Such dynamics have had major implications for the onshore credit bond space, which has had to increasingly turn away from banks and rely on non-bank investors for funding. More specifically, the percentage of credit bonds held by commercial banks declined from 32% in Dec 2014 to 23% in Mar 2020, as Fig 20 shows. Policy bank bonds have gone through a sharper decline with holdings by commercial banks falling from 80% to 57% during the same period. More participation by non-bank investors in the credit space certainly helps improve liquidity. However, at the same time, non-bank investors are much more sensitive to market sentiment than banks, because their own funding costs are higher and more volatile than banks. Such dynamics are likely to continue too, as the supply of Munis remains large because of the fiscal stimulus. On the positive side, if the credit bond space slowly drifts away from being dominated by banks holding the majority of them, it could leave more opportunities for asset managers to play a bigger role in credit investment. 20Y
3% 30Y
5% 2Y 0.2%
15Y
3% 3Y 5%
10Y
26%
5Y 33%
7Y 25%
>10Y <=1Y 10%
12% 7-10Y
16% 1-3Y
23%
5-7Y
17%
3-5Y
22%
17. Munis outstanding, breakdown by investor type Domestic branch of foreign banks 0.18%
Non-bank financial institutions
4%
Offshore foreign investors 0.01%
Others
3%
Policy banks
7%
Other domestic commerial
banks 13%
National commercial banks
73%
Source: Wind, HSBC. Data as of March 2020.
18. Bond holdings by commercial banks, breakdown by type of issuers, Mar 2020 19. Bond holding by commercial banks, breakdown by type of issuers, Dec 2014
Muni 5%
Source: Wind, HSBC Source: Wind, HSBC
20. % of bonds held by commercial banks, Dec 2014 vs Mar 2020 100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
Source: Wind, HSBC
CGB
Munis
Dec 2014
Policy bank bonds
Credit bonds
Mar 2020
All bonds
Credit 21%
CGB 20%
Policy bank
19%
Muni 40%
Credit
25%
CGB
30%
Policy bank
40%
Trading venues Like CGBs, Munis are allowed to be dual-listed in multiple trading venues. Most Munis (or 86% of total outstanding amount) are listed in both the interbank and stock exchange market. Others, or 14% of total outstanding amount, are listed in the interbank market only. Liquidity Poor liquidity has remained a big issue for Munis. As Fig 21 shows, Munis have the second-lowest turnover ratio among all types of bonds in the onshore market, slightly better than complex asset- backed securities (see Asset-backed securities: The time is right, 3 June 2020). This is because of several reasons. A lack of non-bank investors doesn’t help. The dominant investors, commercial banks, do not tend to trade bonds that much in the secondary market. And although the Muni space is large, it is segregated into 38 sub-spaces by the number of issuers, and even the biggest issuer of Munis – Jiangsu Provincial Government – has only RMB1.66trn of bonds outstanding. The market understandably does not tend to trade actively in a small space.
21. Turnover ratio of onshore RMB bond products, 2020 annualised
7.0
6.0
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
-
Policy Bank Bonds
CD Others* CGB Overall Corporates Financial
institutions
Muni ABS
Source: Wind, HSBC
Note: Others are mainly government-sponsored institutions, including China Railw...
- 范文大全
- 职场知识
- 精美散文
- 名著
- 讲坛
- 诗歌
- 礼仪知识
-
超星尔雅学习通《对话大国工匠致敬劳动模范》题库附答案
超星尔雅学习通《对话大国工匠致敬劳动模范》题库附答案 1、历史只会眷顾坚定者、奋进者、搏击者,而不会
【入党申请书】 日期:2021-05-12
-
对于政治生态考核整改工作方案
本文系作者原创投稿,仅供学习参考,请勿照搬照抄! 关于政治生态考核整改工作的方案 为做好推进风清气正
【经济工作】 日期:2020-06-05
-
大学生学习2024年两会精神心得感悟
大学生学习2024年两会精神心得感悟过去一年,是全面贯彻二十大精神的开局之年,中国共产党带领全国各族人民,付出艰辛努力,换来重大成
【心得体会】 日期:2024-03-07
-
中国传统故事英文版 中国古代故事英文版
历史学科蕴含着许多丰富的、生动的、有趣的素材,每一个历史事件、历史人物都有相关的、动人的历史小故事,都能给人以启迪。你对中国古代的故事了解多少呢?下面是小编为您...
【调查报告】 日期:2019-05-22
-
基尔霍夫定律验证实验报告
基尔霍夫定律的验证的实验报告本文关键词:基尔,定律,霍夫,验证,实验基尔霍夫定律的验证的实验报告本文
【思想宣传】 日期:2021-03-08
-
中小学党建工作实施意见
中小学党建设工作实施意见中小学校担负着培养德智体美全面发展的社会主义建设者和接班人的重要使命。加强中
【爱国演讲】 日期:2020-09-22
-
地藏经诵读仪规(完整版)
地藏经诵读仪规(完整版) 恭请文: 恭请大慈大悲大愿地藏王菩萨、护法诸天菩萨慈悲加持护念弟子***能
【个人简历】 日期:2021-03-31
-
小学党建工作制度
小学党建工作制度33篇 党建工作责任制度 1 党支部年初制定全年党建工作计划,将目标任务分解到有关部
【思想学习】 日期:2021-02-10
-
青年学生学习全国人大十四届二次会议心得感想16篇
青年学生学习全国人大十四届二次会议心得感想16篇报告中提到政府在经济调控、消费政策、基础设施和制造业投资、房地产调控以及地方债务
【心得体会】 日期:2024-03-07
-
材料力学考题
材料力学考题本文关键词:材料力学,考题材料力学考题本文简介:材料力学1、简易起重设备中,AC杆由两根
【入党申请书】 日期:2021-03-06
-
执行信息公开网
执行信息公开网 执行信息公开网 执行信息公开网: zhi*ing (点击下图可直接进行访问) 全国
【职场知识】 日期:2020-07-03
-
大学教师毕业设计指导记录4篇
大学教师毕业设计指导记录4篇 毕业设计是指工、农、林科高等学校和中等专业学校学生毕业前夕总结性的独立作业。是实践性教学最后一
【职场知识】 日期:2022-05-11
-
年国家开放大学电大电子商务单选题题库
单选: 1、EDI是指A、电子商务B、电子数据交换C、电子交易 D、移动数据交换 答案: B 2、电
【职场知识】 日期:2020-06-05
-
“以学生为中心”的教学原则
以学生为中心的教学原则教师在开展以学生为中心的教学实践中,必须谨记学习目标不再是知识的获得,能力要比知识更重要。以下是蒲公英阅读网
【职场知识】 日期:2023-01-05
-
有机磷酸酯类中毒及其解救(实验报告范文)
有机磷酸酯类中毒及其解救XXX、XXX一、实验目的1 观察有机磷酸酯类农药敌百虫中毒时的症状。 2
【职场知识】 日期:2020-08-30
-
组工干部学习谈治国理政第三卷《共建创新包容开放型世界经济》心得体会
组工干部学习谈治国理政第三卷《共建创新包容的开放型世界经济》心得体会 《习近平谈治国理政》第三卷第七
【职场知识】 日期:2020-09-22
-
心理健康黑板报_心理健康黑板报图片
虽然工作上难免压力,但是只要正视压力,一切就不会太辛苦。下面就随小编看看心理健康黑板报内容,希望喜欢哦。 心理健康黑板报图片欣赏 心理健康黑板报图片1 心理健...
【职场知识】 日期:2020-02-26
-
2021教育基础知识试题(附答案)
2021教育基础知识精选试题(附答案) 1、主张恢复西方传统教育核心价值,反对“进步教育
【职场知识】 日期:2021-03-17
-
男一分钟仰卧起坐标准表
表表11--13 男生一分钟仰卧起坐、引体向上单项评分表(单位:次) 等级 单项 得分 三年级 四年
【职场知识】 日期:2021-05-08
-
发展党员工作部门联审征求意见表
发展党员工作部门联审征求意见表发展对象姓 名 性别 出生年月 身份证号 现工作单位及职务 家庭住址
【职场知识】 日期:2020-09-22
-
唐代诗人李昂个人信息
唐代诗人李昂个人信息 导读:我根据大家的需要整理了一份关于《唐代诗人李昂个人信息》的内容,具体内容:
【古典文学】 日期:2020-11-07
-
[关于中秋的朗诵诗词] 关于爱国的朗诵诗词
中秋,热闹的街头树起了灯彩,舞起了火龙。你知道多少关于中秋的朗诵诗词?下面小编为你整理了几篇关于中秋的朗诵诗词,希望对你有帮助。 关于中秋的朗诵诗词一 中秋佳节...
【古典文学】 日期:2019-06-06
-
叠加原理实验报告
一、实验目的1、通过实验来验证线性电路中的叠加原理以及其适用范围。 2、学习直流仪器仪表的测试方法。
【古典文学】 日期:2020-11-12
-
输血查对制度
输血查对制度依据卫生部《临床输血技术规范》的要求,制订抽血交叉配备查对制度、取血查对制度、输血查对制
【古典文学】 日期:2020-09-24
-
大气唯美黑板报【国庆节大气黑板报】
日本在投降的那一天,再也没有昔日的嚣张,我们中国的屈辱得到洗刷。下面就随小编看看国庆节大气黑板报内容,希望喜欢哦。 国庆节大气黑板报图片欣赏 国庆节大气黑板报...
【古典文学】 日期:2019-05-05
-
【二人旅游英语情景对话】 二人英语对话2分钟旅游
随着国内外旅游业市场的不断扩大,旅游英语人才成为社会的紧缺人才。小编精心收集了二人旅游英语情景对话,供大家欣赏学习! 二人旅游英语情景对话1 A:Itsmyfirsttimeto...
【古典文学】 日期:2020-02-29
-
怎样认识世界处于百年未有之大变局
怎样认识世界处于百年未有之大变局 首先,“大变局”是对国际格局发生巨大变迁的
【古典文学】 日期:2020-10-28
-
2021公安专业知识考试练习题(附答案)
2021公安专业知识考试练习题(附答案) 1 甲地公安机关接到群众举报,在当天举行的大型娱乐活动中,
【古典文学】 日期:2021-01-29
-
乳糖检测方法
附录A(规范性附录) 乳糖的测定A 1原理牛乳或乳粉样液经沉淀剂澄清后,样液中的乳糖在苯酚、氢氧化钠
【古典文学】 日期:2020-12-08
-
[合作与成功的故事]团队合作成功的案例
学会合作,合作是一种深刻后的美丽,因为一滴水只有融入大海,才能够激起美丽的浪花。关于合作你了解吗?以下是小编分享的合作与成功的故事,一起来和小编看看吧。 合作与成...
【古典文学】 日期:2020-02-27
-
时尚女装店面装修效果图|韩式女装店面装修
在服装店的设计之中,我们要将多变、创新、品牌自身的定位与发展趋势相结合,用一种可持续的设计方式呈现出来,以便更加适应不断更新的展示主体。下面小编就为大家解开时尚女装店...
【中国文学】 日期:2019-05-16
-
2021年超星尔雅学习通《辩论与修养》章节测试试题(共183题附答案)
2021年超星尔雅学习通《辩论与修养》章节测试试题(共183题附答案)1、辩论的目的不是单纯获得某种
【中国文学】 日期:2021-05-12
-
天地人格最佳搭配起名技巧|天地人格的五行怎么算
天地有阴有阳,物体刚柔表里,而数字则有一个诱导力,那么你知道怎么计算天地人格来取名吗?今天小编为你整理了天地人格最佳搭配起名技巧,一起来看看用天地人格取名的方法有哪些...
【中国文学】 日期:2019-06-06
-
信息技术重要性
信息技术的重要性 信息技术与课程整合将带来课程内容的革新,信息技术的高速发展,要求传统的课程必须适应
【中国文学】 日期:2021-02-11
-
2022年当前世界下中国面临国际形势论文范本
和平与发展仍然是当今时代的主题。谋和平、求合作、促发展是各国人民的共同愿望。为了大家学习方便,下面是小编为大家整理的当前世界下中国面临的国际形势论文范文内容,以供参...
【中国文学】 日期:2022-03-31
-
【世界上最大的半岛】阿拉伯半岛
你知道世界上最大的半岛是什么吗?下面由小编来介绍一下。 阿拉伯半岛的简介 阿拉伯半岛(阿拉伯文:)位于亚洲,是世界上最大的半岛。沙特阿拉伯、也门、阿曼、阿拉伯联合...
【中国文学】 日期:2019-05-24
-
古代人物漫画女生唯美图片欣赏 漫画人物图片女孩唯美
中国漫画始于清末民初,而平面设计虽然其名称是在改革开放以后确立的,但设计活动却自古就有,二者的相互影响是本文的主要讨论范围。小编整理了唯美古代女生人物漫画,欢迎阅读!...
【中国文学】 日期:2020-03-19
-
雪天安全行车注意事项_雪天安全行车提示语
维护城市交通秩序,争做河源文明市民。你们想看看雪天安全行车提示语有哪些吗?以下是小编推荐雪天安全行车提示语给大家,欢迎大家阅读! 安全行车温馨提示语【经典篇】 1...
【中国文学】 日期:2020-03-15
-
2021年5月时事政治热点(国内+国际)
2021年年5月时事政治热点(国内+国际)国内部分 1 55月月66日,由商务部和海南省人民政府共同
【中国文学】 日期:2021-06-10
-
关于通过努力获得成功的故事:靠自己努力成功的例子
努力,是成功的一半。人生道路上难免会遇到挫折,但我们不应后退,应向理想之路奋勇前进。关于名人努力成功的故事你了解吗?以下是小编分享的关于通过努力获得成功的故事,一起...
【中国文学】 日期:2020-03-03
-
改革开放大事记简表(改革开放新时期1978-2012年)
改革开放大事记简表 (1978-2012年) 时间1978年12月18日至22日地点北京事件党的十一
【外国名著】 日期:2021-06-17
-
山东省生产经营单位安全生产主体责任规定(303号令)
山东省生产经营单位安全生产主体责任规定(2013年2月2日山东省人民政府令第260号公布根据2016
【外国名著】 日期:2020-10-22
-
大学生音乐欣赏论文 大学音乐鉴赏论文3000
今天小编就为你介绍关于大学生音乐欣赏论文,下面是!小编给你搜集了相关资料!希望可以能帮助到大家。 大学生音乐欣赏论文—第一篇 音乐是生活不可缺少的一部分,学会欣...
【外国名著】 日期:2019-05-27
-
材料力学金属扭转实验报告
材料力学金属扭转实验报告 【实验目的】 1、验证扭转变形公式,测定低碳钢的切变模量G。;测定低碳钢和
【外国名著】 日期:2020-11-27
-
长豆角家常做法怎么做好吃营养 炒豆角的家常做法
豆角在我们日常生活中是很常见的食材,可能我们只知道它含有优质蛋白和维生素,其实它还有其他的营养价值。它也是可以和很多食材做搭配的。下面小编为大家整理了长豆角的做法...
【外国名著】 日期:2020-02-26
-
(新版)就业知识竞赛题库及答案解析
(新版)就业知识竞赛题库(全真题库) 一、单选题1 (单选):在职业生涯规划工具中,组织在展开员工职
【外国名著】 日期:2021-07-21
-
植物装饰画黑白图片欣赏|荷花装饰画黑白图片
装饰画是一种装饰性艺术,是装饰性和创造性相结合的艺术设计形式。小编整理了植物装饰画黑白,欢迎阅读! 植物装饰画黑白图片展示 植物装饰画黑白图片1 植物装饰画黑白...
【外国名著】 日期:2019-05-31
-
坚定不移全面从严管党治警研讨发言稿
坚定不移全面从严管党治警研讨发言稿政治建警、从严治警是党在新时代的建警治警方针。一年前的全国公安工作
【外国名著】 日期:2020-09-18
-
白烛葵的花语:白烛葵的不死幻想症
白烛葵,花名,花语为“不感兴趣”。现又指《知音漫客》上连载漫画《极度分裂》里主要角色之一。下面小编为你整理了白烛葵的花语。欢迎阅读。 白烛葵的花语:不感兴趣 ...
【外国名著】 日期:2019-05-11
-
把脉人力资源管理的风向标 什么是风向标
把脉人力资源管理的风向标 外部经营环境的巨大变化,不可避免地给身处其中的企业及其经营管理带来新的、深刻的变化和挑战:市场需求在明显萎缩;而买方市场中,客户要求
【外国名著】 日期:2019-09-04
-
梧桐花的花语|梧桐花的功效与作用
梧桐花为梧桐科植物梧桐的花,植物形态详梧桐子条。今天小编为你整理了梧桐花的花语,欢迎阅读。 梧桐花的花语是:情窦初开 在春季里晚开的花朵,有着恬淡的气息。 ...
【寓言童话】 日期:2020-03-03
-
西部计划笔试题库(99题含答案)
西部计划笔试题库(99题含答案) 1 第十三届全国人大三次会议表决通过了《中华人民共和国民法典》,自
【寓言童话】 日期:2021-06-16
-
大学生音乐欣赏论文 大学音乐鉴赏论文3000
今天小编就为你介绍关于大学生音乐欣赏论文,下面是!小编给你搜集了相关资料!希望可以能帮助到大家。 大学生音乐欣赏论文—第一篇 音乐是生活不可缺少的一部分,学会欣...
【寓言童话】 日期:2020-03-12
-
年学生资助诚信教育主题活动方案
各二级学院(部): 为深入贯彻落实习近平总书记关于教育的重要论述,落实立德树人根本任务,增强当代大学
【寓言童话】 日期:2020-06-21
-
油管、套管规格尺寸对照表
API油管规格及尺寸 公称尺寸(in) 不加厚外径(mm) 不加厚内径(mm) 加厚外径(mm) 加
【寓言童话】 日期:2020-08-31
-
主题教育调查研究工作方案2篇
主题教育调查研究工作方案1根据省、市、县开展“不忘初心、牢记使命”主题教育工
【寓言童话】 日期:2021-03-19
-
惊悚鬼故事50字 令人惊悚的故事
这些惊悚故事在短短的篇幅和时间之内让您感受到故事里传达出来的恐怖感,令你感到害怕。下面就是小编给大家整理的令人惊悚的故事,希望对你有用! 令人惊悚的故事篇1:学校...
【寓言童话】 日期:2019-05-13
-
【古代男生漫画图片大全】男生漫画头像
漫画和动画组成了动漫产业的两大支柱。然而,与动画相比,漫画在业界和学界皆相对冷清。小编整理了古代男生漫画,欢迎阅读! 古代男生漫画图片展示 古代男生漫画图片1 ...
【寓言童话】 日期:2019-05-27
-
读《李光耀观天下》有感_李光耀观天下txt在线读
务实与真诚 ——读《李光耀观天下》有感 原创:雁过留声ly 购于北大,在出差的飞机和高铁上读完,这本《李光耀观天下》给予我很多启示。严格地说,这本书没有详
【寓言童话】 日期:2019-05-05
-
北京最好吃的自助餐厅 北京高档自助餐排名
自助餐简直就是拯救大胃王的最佳饮食!没有之一!世界上没有什么事情是吃一顿自助餐解决不了的,如果有,那就吃两顿!下面小编给大家推荐北京几家好吃的自助餐。 北京最好吃的...
【寓言童话】 日期:2020-02-25
-
学生高考动员演讲稿
学生高考动员演讲稿3篇高考动员演讲稿11 老师们、同学们: 大家下午好!漫漫高考长征路已经进入尾声了
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-09-22
-
企业安全演讲稿2021
最新企业安全的演讲稿5篇 演讲稿是作为在特定的情境中供口语表达使用的文稿。在充满活力,日益开放的今天
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-09-22
-
XX镇扶贫项目实施专项整治工作总结_1
XX镇扶贫项目实施专项整治工作总结 为深入贯彻精准扶贫精准脱贫基本方略,认真落实党中央、国务院,省委
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-09-22
-
对乡镇领导班子干部成员批评意见例文
对乡镇领导班子干部成员的批评看法范文 一、对党委书记XXX同志的批评看法〔3条〕 1、与干部交流偏少
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-09-22
-
群英乡扶贫资金项目芬坡村祖埇村生产道路硬化工程绩效自评报告
群英乡扶贫资金项目((芬坡村祖埇村生产道路硬化工程))绩效自评报告 一、基本情况(一)群英乡扶贫资金
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-09-22
-
党委书记警示教育大会上讲话2021汇编
党委书记在警示教育大会上的讲话55篇汇编 党委书记在警示教育大会上的讲话(一) 同志们: 根据省州委
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-09-22
-
对于2021年召开巡视整改专题民主生活会对照检查材料
关于12021年召开巡视整改专题民主生活会对照检查材料 按照中央巡视组要求和省、市、区委统一部署,区
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-08-14
-
消防安全知识培训试题.doc
消防安全知识培训试题姓名: 部门班组: 成绩: 一:填空题,每空4分,共44分。 1、灭火剂是通过隔
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-08-14
-
涉疫重点人员“五包一”居家隔离医学观察工作流程
涉疫重点人员“五包一”居家隔离医学观察工作流程 目前,全球疫情仍处于大流行状
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-08-14
-
疫情防控致全体师生员工及家长一封信
疫情防控致全体师生员工及家长的一封信 各位师生员工及全体家长朋友: 暑假已至,近期我省部分地方发现确
【百家讲坛】 日期:2021-08-14